Showing posts with label Mistakes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Mistakes. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 10, 2007

Mistake 3 - The most unlucky stock picker

Ever had any of the following experiences?

Found a stock that meet all the criterias you were looking for, nice valuation, good business prospects and etc.. but, you were not sure when to call your broker to make the Buy order... you waited and waited for the "feeling" to call on you as you watched the stock kept its upward push, slow and steady.. and one fine morning, you suddenly saw one hell of a good news about this particular stock in the newspaper and the projections is that its profit is going to double (for whatever reasons..) in the next financial year (or whatever good news you can imagine).. "oh my god.. this thing is gonna shoot up today.. I am gonna miss the boat!!" you told yourself.. as the market opened, the stock suddenly gaped up for like 5% and it never look back since then.. you can wait no more and you know that you just NEED to call the broker RIGHT AWAY!! ...

"Hey, Tom, buy me 5 lots of SOB Holding Limited, whatever price it is selling, quick quick, don't let it runs away.." (you might even called the wrong name, whatever, who cares!!) all you know is that you need to buy that SOB or else you will be kicking yourself if it hits limit up.. as you waited for ages to get the order confirmation from your broker, your mind were thinking, "what the hell!! does he even know how to use a computer? My grandma could have keyed in the order faster than he does! if he don't get it done in the next minute, I swear I am going to change a remisier"... "bloody hell, is he done yet?"... "ok, Done!!" as Tom (or Harry, whatever) confirmed the execution of the order, you heaved s sigh of relief *phew*, "oh yeah! I am on the boat now.. c'mon, let's ride, show papa what you can do"..

eh? suddenly, you saw the buying discontinued, and all the sell orders started to pile up.. 1 cents lower, 2 cents lower.. 5 cents lower.. and as the buy orders disappeared, the fall started to gather momentum.. 10 cents lower, 15 cents, and in just a few minutes, 20 cents off the peak which you've just bought.. "what the hell?".. and without long, it was back to where it closed yesterday, and stayed there for the whole day.. you were shocked, you were disappointed.. but yet, things didn't improve over the next few days.. 1 cent up, 2 cents down, 3 cents up, 4 cents down.. as it went side-ways for the next few weeks, you suddenly let your anger took control of you and you've decided to cut loses and sold it off at whatever price it was.. you thought that's the end of the story eh? heh.. the nice part had just begun.. the stock started to climb... (I leave the rest for your imagination..)

Does this all or any part of it sounds familiar? And you thought that you are the most unlucky stock picker in the world? and you are born to be a loser?

Don't be. Honestly, I have been through that too.. made some hasty decision when my emotions took control of me. I've learnt some painful lessons, luckily I didn't have much capital to invest in back then, or else I would have hurt myself even worse. And, I realised there are many others who have had the similar experiences.

What triggered me to write out this blog? I read something interesting from a book called "Hedgehogging", written by Barton Biggs (finally, something else away from Warren Buffett eh?). The book is about his life being a fund manager, worth your time if you are thinking of becoming one.. Anyway, since you've been reading until here, I don't mind to share with you here.. below is an ad, printed in the "Bawl Street Journal" in 1980 which Biggs had shared in the book, and it goes like this:

PROFIT FROM OUR MISTAKES!!
Investing money is a zero sum game. For every winner, there is a loser. We've been losers! If you had sold what we bought, and if you had bought what we sold, you would be rich!

In 1968, we went heavily into stocks and by 1974, we're down almost 50%! In 1973-1975, we invested over $150 million in real estate, and not just any real estate -- we concentrated in Atlanta; We lost our ass! In 1978, we hired a bright theoretical consultant from Harvard who had a "yield tilt" model which told us that energy stocks were overpriced and auto stocks cheap. This seemed to make sense, so we sold Texas Oil and Gas at $8 and bought General Motors at $60. We lost 33% of our money. If you had gone the other way, you'd be up 430%!
All investors make some bad decisions. But we make a lot -- and with consistency. Now for the first time, you can profit from our mistakes. For $10,000 a year, you can receive copies of the minutes of our quarterly Finance Committee meetings in which we establish our investment philosophy. For an additional $25,000 a year, we will give you a monthly update over the telephone of our current market outlook. And for only $100,000 a year you will receive copies of our trade confirmations so you will know on a daily basis what not to do. It's part of our Contrarian Theory.
This may seem like a very unusual offer, but look at it this way: we can't seem to get on the right side of markets, so if we let you pay to profit from our mistakes, we will have finally found a way to profit from our mistakes as well.
Subscribe now. Time is limited. We are about to undertake a major restructuring of the portfolio, and we'd hate to see you get caught going the SAME way.

- THE FORD FOUNDATION
Feel better? See, I am (or, we are) not alone. Even the professionals and experts did have their bad times. So? should we blame it on luck? or should we just give up investing totally? Well, I have chosen my path long ago. I have chosen to stick to Value Investing. If there are already so many successful investors out there, there must be a way that works! Learn from them! Learn from Mistakes! Have a little Faith and move on!

Sunday, October 07, 2007

Mistake 2: The Wrong Management Team

(With addendum in red)

One of the costly mistakes I have made during my not-so-long investing career is to entrust my hard earned money onto companies with not-so-good management team.

There are numerous examples that happened on our own soil here in Malaysia recently that proved that I am not the only one that have to learn from this mistake. Transmile, Megan Media, Wimems, F-Tec.. just to name a few, have seen their share prices hammered badly due to questionings by SC on suspicions of wrong-doings within the companies. I am pretty sure there are still many similar cases out there, and it's going to be up to us as an investor, to be extra cautious when picking stocks.

But the questions is, how do we know if the company is managed by trustworthy people? Here are some of my humble thoughts:

a) Most importantly, refer to the financial statements and compare them across a few years. Good management should exhibit capability to grow revenue while cutting down costs, widening the profit margin, continually generating high returns on capitals over the years and etc. All in all, making more money for the shareholders. For the sake of this topic, let's just keep to these simple stuff.

b) Another more entertaining way compared to reading those boring numbers is to read the Chairman and MD's statements in the annual reports. Trust me, these statements tell alot about the person in charge. Ever read/heard about the world famous "Letter to Shareholders" written by Warren Buffett himself in the annual report of Berkshire Hathaway? In these letters, Buffett explains the performance of the company for the year, and some major decisions made by himself and some of his thoughts that he wanted to share with his shareholders (or usually referred to as Partners). These letters are treated like Bible by the investment community and there are people who try really hard to study the philosophies and principles of the legendary investor, as well as to find clues about his next move from these letters.

Besides, I especially like to read those statements by Chairman where the companies are in the red. It is usually interesting to see how they tried to cover the holes and give unreasonable excuses to us shareholders (when he thinks that we are suckers). These are usually followed by some very optimistic projections about the future and promising ways to improve the condition. Hmm.. if they already know what need to be done, why haven't they start doing them? Worse, sometimes I feel like they didn't even write those statements themselves..

c) Take a look at the Directors' Salaries and Remuneration package. I prefer those below 5% relative to the Net Profit. You can have your own threshold, depends on your generosity.

d) Read the newspaper and Internet. They might give some clues on what the person in charge is working on at the moment, and sometimes, their characters. I've heard jokes (or real cases, I don't know) where some "people" fly first class to meet their girl friends in London, bought a penthouse for them as "investment in strategic properties" with the companies' fund, buy a multi million dollars paintings as "furniture and fittings" for the office and etc, all in the company's expenses. I didn't say these are all wrong, my point is: Rich people have different hobbies from us ordinary people... Well, some of them might be really beneficial to the shareholders, hell knows. Why bother with these stuff? Mr Buffett once said something like: if the CEO of the company is someone you are comfortable to marry your daughter to, then it is the right business to invest in (well, of course with the assumption you don't hate your daughter). So, don't you want to know a little more about your potential son-in-law?

e) Lastly, this might need you to put in some effort to master the skill. Ever heard of a type of Asian fortune telling skill called "Face reading"? This is defined in Wikipedia as ".. the interpretation of facial features of the nose, eyes, mouth and other criteria within one's face and the conversion of those criteria into predictions for the future... usually covers one phase of the client's life, and reveals the type of luck associated with a certain age range". Once you master the skill, go look at all the pictures/portraits of the directors in the annual reports. Believe it or not, it might even be more accurate and effective than all those other methods mentioned above.

(Seriously, ignore the last one, I am merely writing to make up the numbers)

Addendum on 10/10/07: One big mistake I have made was that I overlooked the impact of management can have on a business/stock. I used to pick "undervalued" stocks by looking only at the numbers in the financial statements and totally ignored the intergrity of the management at the helm. From my experience, there are more homework need to be done. No matter how good the business prospect is; or how dominating it is in its market; or how "cheaply valued" the stock is, as long as you have someone stupid/dishonest/incapable/selfish/greedy (or whatever bad characteristics you can think of) up there, you won't see the stock performing well in long term. Period.

Friday, May 11, 2007

Mistakes, alot I have made - Act 1

I must confess, I have made alot of mistakes in my life as an investor. I would like to share some of them every now and then, hoping someone who read my blog might learn them the easier and cheaper way. I would also try to share my experience on how to deal with them and not to remake the mistakes.

The most important lesson that I have learnt from my past mistakes is "buying shares based on rumours without checking further into its fundamental". I have been repeating this mistake again and again without noticing it. There are instances that look so true that those who told me the news are willing to bet their head or sworn in the name of whoever they can think of. I didn't say that all news are fake, but it has to make sense, at least. Some common news are like "this company will be securing a contract or have signed an MOU with a super billionaire in China"; "someone has offered to take over the company, buy now before the price shot up.."; "this company is going to declare capital repayment of a few ringgits, the price will shoot up..", "some syndicates have signed agreement with the owner to push up the price.." and many more.

Any one of them sound familiar? Well, you are so lucky if you haven't heard any of them. yup, lucky. I've heard a couple dozens of them even though my main carear is not in the finance industry. I admit there are news that really came true, u know, once a while, but the chances of it NOT coming true are much more higher. Allow me to use another examples from gambling: How often have you heard people winning from the casinos? I do, occassionally. But the losers far outnumbered the winners. Even the winners will usually lose after a few successful runs, and usually, the losses are much more than those he had won in the past.

However, it is sometimes very hard to ignore rumours, isn't it? aren't you afraid that the rumours might turn out to be true and you are the only one left behind as the share price sky rocketed? Your uncles, aunties, brothers, sisters, neighbours, mother in law, daughter of your third grand auntie and etc are all singing praises for the syndicate while you hide at the corner kicking yourself? I kindda get use to this thinking myself.

However, if you really have to jump on the bandwagon regardless where it is heading, there are 2 questions you should ask yourself in advance.
1) What's the probability the rumours will come true?
This will require your rationale and sometimes a little logic thinking. One simple example: a company is going to have a capital repayment exercise. The easiest way is to find out whether the company have sufficient fund to do so. And, who is going to benefit from this? If the company is already in deep financial difficulties, how can they afford to do so?

Question 2, might require some homework to be done, ask yourself: What if the news doesn't come true?
It's back to fundamental analysis. There shall be a "margin of safety" or worst case scenario, if you were to hold on to the share. Let's say, a company is quoted at RM1/share and there is rumours that another company will take over them for RM1.50 per share. Your valuation told you that it shall at least worth RM1.20/share. So, in case the deal hasn't materialised, you will still be holding a share bought at a discount anyway.

Conclusion, avoid rumours and concentrate on Fundamental Analysis, if you can; else, don't forget the latter.